Sounds like another fun read:
He left her without a word…
Now he needs her help to catch a killer.
Escaping his Amish community as a teen was about survival, but leaving meant breaking LizBeth Troyer’s heart. Now Detective Jackson Lapp is working a cold case—and the clue to a murdered Amish girl’s identity leads him back to his hometown. Can Jackson and LizBeth rebuild their broken trust and work together to catch a killer before another young Amish woman is murdered?
Other Books
SO MANY!!!!!! 
I’ll be honest. I’m not especially into Amish novels, so I haven’t reviewed many of those, but every book I’ve read by Shelley Gray has been well-written and enjoyable. She is an author it is easy to recommend.
Rumors in Ross County Series
- Edgewater Road
Love Inspired Cold Case Inspirational Romance
- Widow’s Secret (reviewed here)
- Amish Jane Doe
Berlin Bookmobile Series
- A Perfect Amish Romance
- An Amish Surprise
- A Christmas Courtship (Coming October 19!)
Walnut Creek
- Friends To the End: A Prequel Novella
- The Patient One
- The Loyal One
- A Precious Gift
- The Protective One
- The Trustworthy One
- Promises of Tomorrow
Bridgeport Social Club
Dance With Me
- Shall We Dance
- Take the Lead
- Save The Last Dance
Amish of Hart County
- Her Secret
- His Guilt
- The Gift
- His Risk
- Her Fear
- His Promise
- An Amish Homecoming
- The Courage to Love
Lone Star Hero’s Love Story
- The Loyal Heart
- An Uncommon Protector
- Love Held Captive
Amish Brides of Pinecraft
- The Promise of Palm Grove
- The Proposal At Siesta Key
- A Wedding at the Orange Blossom Inn
- A Christmas Bride in Pinecraft
- A Wish on Gardenia Street
- A Reunion in Pinecraft
A Chicago World’s Fair Mystery
- Secrets of Sloane House
- Deception on Sable Hill
- Whispers in the Reading Room
Charmed Amish Life
- A Son’s Vow
- A Daughter’s Dream
- A Sister’s Wish
- An Amish Family Christmas
- Their Second Chance Novella
Stand Alone Historicals
Seasons of Sugarcreek
- Winter’s Awakening
- Spring’s Renewal
- Autumn’s Promise
- Christmas in Sugarcreek
Return to Sugarcreek
- Hopeful
- Thankful
- Joyful
Days of Redemption
- Daybreak
- Ray of Light
- Eventide
- Snowfall
The Secrets of Crittenden County
- Missing
- The Search
- Found
- Peace
Sisters of the Heart
- Hidden
- Wanted
- Forgiven
- Grace
- Sisters of the Heart Trilogy
Families of Honor
- The Caregiver
- The Protector
- The Survivor
- A Christmas for Katie
Heart of a Hero
- A Texan’s Promise
- A Texan’s Honor
- A Texan’s Choice
- An Outlaw’s Heart Novella
Novellas
- A Reunion in Pinecraft
- An Outlaw’s Heart Novella
- The Courage to Love
- Amish Christmas Twins
- Amish Midwives
